Literature in Schools Poisoned the “Nigeria Mind”

Posted: October 10, 2014 in Corruption, Governance, Institutions
Tags: , , , , , , , ,
This was the role model for generations of Nigerian primary school children.

This was Ali the role model for generations of Nigerian primary school children.

It is easy to deride Nigeria and Nigerians because there are ample bases for it and its often convenient; “Nigeria is a Nation of Thieves” as Colin Powell once said or “Nigeria is a Nation of 419ers” or “Nigeria is the most Corrupt Nation in the World” etc. Such derision about Nigeria is mostly about deception and corruption. Unsurprisingly, these vices can be said to be surreptitiously caused in the national primary education institution of the 1970s onwards, attributable to the “New Oxford English Course Reader” (NOECR); the only literature, virtually poison, available to primary school kids in the curriculum.

The NOECR is an English language textbook. It ran two story series. The first series is about “John and Ayi”, siblings who go on a trip with their parents round Nigeria visiting key locations. The moral is to educate the primary school pupils in the rich diversity of Nigerian people and places. It is totally useless for the purpose! Less than 1% of Nigerian children get to enjoy the thrills of tourism. Furthermore, a Yoruba professor in the Geography of Nigeria will tell you Bini man or Ibibio man is Igbo; an Igbo Professor in the Anthropology of Nigeria will tell you a man from Tiv or Birom is Hausa; and a Hausa professor of the Town and Regional planning of Nigeria will tell you Warri is in India or Eket is in China. If professors on these subjects cannot understand ethnic and regional differences, how could primary kids?

The second series is about an Oriental scoundrel, Ali, who is crouching, cunning, thieving, heartless, furtive and deceptive (cf Orientalism by Edward Said). Ali is portrayed in stories in the NOECR like “Tea without Sugar” and “Ali and the Angel” etc.; the stories narrate the workings of a skilful con artist and a villain that wins by his tricks anyway. This second series is far more interesting than the first to kids. By instinctive morality, Ali was not a role model kids could speak about with their parents or adults nor could they identify with him among peers; they simply internalised him. Ali had to be sublimated passively in their minds and from there he wreaks havoc today. This was a very powerful but poisonous influence on the minds of children in school in the name of education. It should not go unnoticed.

How did the NOECR get into the Nigerian primary school curriculum? Why was it not protested by Nigeria’s innumerable educationists? Is Africa devoid of heroes, real or imaginary, that kids could learn about? What kind of role model is Ali to be subliminally deposited in the psyche of Nigerians now in their 30s, 40s and 50s?

Having been raised in the UK in primary school my first class was read a host of fairy tales by our teacher. At seven I went off to boarding school. I arrived half way through the term and the story “The Secret of Skeleton Island” by Robert Arthur was being read to my class. In next three terms a most gifted but brutal teacher read us “Treasure Island” by R L Stevenson, an adventure story of British dominion and pride; “The Hobbit” by TRR Tolkien, a story of outstanding imagination and imagery; and “Robinson Crusoe” by Daniel Defoe which has endued me with admiration for the human spirit in or outside adversity. The teacher did not only read to us, he would explain the context, history and meanings of these stories. It was a sound and non-materialistic education, I was nearly nine then.

A nine-year old Nigerian kid already knows his father has to build a house / buy a jeep to gain respect. Or that her mother should never share any information that would benefit others. Or that when he grows up he would never ‘trek’ (walk any use public road transport) but own cars. Or that she is going to marry a wealthy man when she grows up because she does not want to suffer. When these things are not possible or available, Ali rears his head in their head. Nigerian kids grow up too fast to materialism and their expectation are obscenely high; greed and corruption is inevitable. The members of the society of in which these kids live are graduates (or victims) of “Ali-poisoned psyche”, yet we expect discipline, fairness, trust, conduct from citizen as morality or civic responsibility. This may sound like extremely unfair blame on primary education but as Proverbs 22:6 declares, “Train a child in the way he should go, and even when he is old he will not turn away from it“, one does not have to be a Christian or Jew to agree.

The “Ali psyche” transmission is undeniable.

The solution to this most tragic mis-education may be simple on paper but incredibly difficult in practice. De-conditioning Nigerian adults to not think like Ali is almost unthinkable. However, for the future children should be allowed to be children again, at least through their early formal education and the story books should contain characters that definitively make a Better Society.

 

Grimot Nane

Comments
  1. atamssokari says:

    Sir, I had my nursery and primary education in Port Harcourt between ’95 and 2002. In that time, we did not study “Ali Baba and the Forty Thieves” and your article is the first place I am reading of “John and Ayi”. Perhaps, my private primary school education is a reason for that difference.

    I remember tales of “Ali & Simbi” though, Okon and Edet featured often too. In those series, by Macmillian Press I think, the authors focused on parts of Nigerian geography: Oron, Eket for Okon & Edet. The course books for English Language also featured excerpts from books by Nigerian authors as well as some foreign books. Again, it is possible this was a privilege for the private school educated.

    I follow your line of thought though. It is important that pupils are taught using tools that promote good moral and civil standing. The books I read, did. This is a place where administrators of public school education should come in. Left to me, I think those in charge presently have failed and new administrators should be put in place. However, our Civil Service, Local, State & Federal, cannot attract the best and the brightest. They also tend to frustrate those who wish to effect change.

    Oh well! What do I know?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s